Frost's Circle
In 1953, A. A. Frost [J. Chem. Phys., 1953, 21, 572] noted that the symmetry of monocyclic conjugated systems (Huckel aromatics) made possible a simple description of the relative energies of their molecular orbitals.
The process is straightforward:
- Draw a circle of radius 2b.
- Inside the circle, inscribe the regular polygon corresponding to the molecule of interest
- One vertex must be pointed downward
- All vertices must just touch the circle
The positions of the vertices then describe the energies of the molecular orbitals.
- Orbitals with negative energies are bonding; those with positive energies are antibonding
- Orbitals of zero (or a) energy are non bonding
For example:
The diagram on the left represents benzene. The six p-electrons then may be placed in the orbitals with spins paired, beginning with the lowest. The six electrons just fill all the bonding orbitals.
- Note the degeneracy of both HOMO and LUMO.
Notice that the 4n + 2 rule falls naturally out of this diagram: two electrons for the single orbital of lowest energy, and four for each doubly degenerate level.
On the right is cyclobutadiene, with four p-electrons.
- Again, the HOMO is degenerate.
- Since Hund's rule won't let us pair electrons in an orbital until there is no other option, Frost's circle predicts cyclobutadiene to be a diradical.
Note that this scheme only works for regular polygons. If cyclobutadiene is not square, it doesn't have to be a diradical.
- In fact, the Jahn-Teller effect predicts that such a species should distort so as to remove the degeneracy of the half-filled orbitals.
- When finally synthesized at 77 K in an argon glass, cyclobutadiene was found to be rectangular, with all electrons paired.
This page last modified 2:11 PM on Friday October 14th, 2011.
Webmaster, Department of Chemistry, University of Maine, Orono, ME 04469